Surely better to pick a team with reasons for selection?
Sytze Bijker - When Sytze gets away from you he's totally unplayable, if you lunge out to defend he runs you, if you don't he's shooting undefended and will score. Defence needs a bit of work but his opposition boy will never outscore him.
Davesh Patel - Power, strength, a great shot, a great collect and a player who seems to be very hard to defend against.
Sam Brooks - He punishes weaker sides from open play more than any other player and will keep the scoreboard ticking over nicely and if a team restricts him, the other boys in this selection will score. The ultimate plan b option.
Ean Irwin - Flair and skill and he can shoot off the jump and his rebound play is ridiculously good for a short guy.
The most underrated boy in the four I've named despite being 5th top scorer in NL currently.
He brings something to the team that nobody else in the NL really has in that I enjoy watching him play as an individual rather than as a goalscoring robot. He'll try something interesting and liven up a game. In an All Star game this is what you want.
Steph Allen - I've never seen an opposition girl want to play against her and she brings a great goalscoring record, a good collect and a physical game. If your girls hate playing against somebody, you want them in your all stars team.
Emma Cole - A beautiful shooting technique from mid to long range, capable of running her player and a quite aggressive defence if you can wind her up the right way.
Sarah-Jane Spice - Consistent goalscoring at the top level for many years, every time I've seen her play she's racked up the goals and you don't win international caps for nothing.
The fourth girl is difficult, you want to avoid a flat track bully who scores highly against weaker sides but is shut out by the top sides.
Experience wise you have Sparrow & Holness, elsewhere you have most of the England squad and then even players like Aimee Evans who've been out of the EKL for a while but have proven records.
Since I'm struggling to decide I'm going to go with Rebecca Clements (who I think I've only seen play once) since anybody who can stick 7 goals past Trojans and be near the top of the scoring charts has to be worth a call up!
Since I've never played higher than LKA1 I reckon I'm safe from a backlash but I'd love to see a more detailed explanation of choices from people who've played at the top level.